IEEE 802.1 Web Tally
Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1Qay/D4.5
Tallied VotesOther Information
Approve [*]22 (%79)Pass / Fail [**]Pass
Disapprove6 (%21)Last Updated2008-11-14
Abstain [*]43 (%61)Non-Voting Comments [*]0
Total71ParticipationClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List 71 / 107  Task Force 9
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve"
   Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain"
   Non-Voting Comments are just "Comments"
** To "Pass": Approval Percent >= 75% and Work Group Parcipation >= 50%

Ballot Votes
Participant Vote Date
Boatright, RobertWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 10:36:55 2008
Mace GaelWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 10:48:14 2008
Karen RandallWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 11:46:01 2008
Olsen, DaveWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 12:49:37 2008
Diego CrupnicoffWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 13:29:02 2008
Gunther, CraigWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 13:41:19 2008
Matthew Xavier MoraWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Oct 07 18:08:34 2008
Maarten VissersWorking Group Participant Disapprove Wed Oct 08 07:37:24 2008
Brian WeisTask Force Participant Abstain Wed Oct 08 12:28:06 2008
Mitchell GusatWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Oct 09 09:52:55 2008
Glen ZornWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Oct 10 13:45:41 2008
David PetersonWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Oct 13 11:08:58 2008
Geoffrey M. GarnerWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Oct 13 16:31:16 2008
Tony JeffreeTask Force Participant Abstain Thu Oct 16 05:54:41 2008
Francois Tallet (ftallet)Working Group Participant Abstain Thu Oct 16 15:26:00 2008
BONNAMY Jean-michel RD-RESA-LANWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Oct 17 04:31:00 2008
Winkel, LudwigWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Oct 17 11:45:51 2008
Manoj WadekarWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Oct 17 13:04:18 2008
Bruce KwanWorking Group Participant Abstain Sun Oct 19 01:34:18 2008
Mike KoWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Oct 23 12:56:13 2008
Marco MascittoWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Oct 23 15:03:27 2008
Keti Kilcrease (kilcreas)Working Group Participant Abstain Fri Oct 24 15:21:57 2008
John Nels FullerWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Oct 24 18:40:03 2008
Michael WrightTask Force Participant Abstain Fri Oct 24 21:39:40 2008
Caitlin BestlerWorking Group Participant Abstain Sat Oct 25 14:13:38 2008
Paul CongdonWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Oct 27 19:56:17 2008
Henry (Chien-Hsien) WuWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Oct 29 20:27:03 2008
Anoop GhanwaniWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Oct 30 23:41:15 2008
Abhay KarandikarWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Sun Nov 02 03:27:39 2008
Ao TingTask Force Participant Comments (With Abstain) Mon Nov 03 10:10:45 2008
Grewal, KenTask Force Participant Abstain Mon Nov 03 11:50:35 2008
David MartinWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Mon Nov 03 15:23:46 2008
Romascanu, Dan (Dan)Working Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Tue Nov 04 06:57:56 2008
Hiroshi OhtaWorking Group Participant Approve Tue Nov 04 07:21:31 2008
Hesham ElbakouryWorking Group Participant Approve Tue Nov 04 14:01:22 2008
Hal KeenWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 12:28:22 2008
Eric GrayWorking Group Participant Approve Wed Nov 05 13:10:16 2008
Stanton, Kevin BWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 13:10:21 2008
Alon, Zehavit (NSN - IL/Hod HaSharon)Working Group Participant Disapprove Wed Nov 05 13:12:24 2008
Joseph Salowey (jsalowey)Working Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 14:46:44 2008
Satish SatheWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 15:25:25 2008
Mick SeamanWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 16:01:00 2008
Joe Pelissier (jopeliss)Working Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 17:30:43 2008
Menu MenuchehryWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 18:23:26 2008
Attila TakacsWorking Group Participant Approve Wed Nov 05 18:37:18 2008
Muneyoshi SuzukiWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 19:31:03 2008
Bob SultanTask Force Participant Comments (With Approve) Wed Nov 05 20:48:09 2008
SETO, KoichiroWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 20:56:08 2008
Yan WangWorking Group Participant Approve Wed Nov 05 22:06:38 2008
Claudio DeSantiWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Nov 05 23:44:18 2008
Riccardo MartinottiWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 05:43:28 2008
kari . laihonenWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 07:52:31 2008
Janos FarkasWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 09:15:40 2008
Alan McGuireWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 11:00:58 2008
Yong KimWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 12:48:41 2008
Don PannellWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Nov 06 13:46:09 2008
Kevin NolishWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 13:53:02 2008
Asif HazarikaWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Nov 06 14:17:56 2008
Glenn ParsonsWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Thu Nov 06 14:26:49 2008
Sprecher, Nurit (NSN - IL/Hod HaSharon)Working Group Participant Disapprove Thu Nov 06 16:44:50 2008
Craig W. CarlsonWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Nov 06 21:21:39 2008
Prakash KashyapWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Thu Nov 06 21:40:26 2008
Jessy V RouyerWorking Group Participant Disapprove Thu Nov 06 23:03:19 2008
David Elie-Dit-CosaqueWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Nov 06 23:08:15 2008
Don FedykTask Force Participant Approve Thu Nov 06 23:55:56 2008
Ben Mack-CraneWorking Group Participant Disapprove Fri Nov 07 00:26:57 2008
Stephen HaddockWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Fri Nov 07 01:39:22 2008
Panagiotis SaltsidisWorking Group Participant Approve Fri Nov 07 04:13:40 2008
yannick1 . legoffWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Nov 07 04:19:42 2008
INSLER Romain RD-RESA-LANWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Nov 07 09:05:45 2008
Roese, JosefWorking Group Participant Approve Fri Nov 07 10:13:23 2008
Zhemin DINGTask Force Participant Comments (With Approve) Fri Nov 07 10:58:32 2008
Raghu KondapalliWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Nov 07 12:30:27 2008
Ken YoungWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Fri Nov 07 17:33:06 2008
Linda DunbarWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Nov 07 17:41:08 2008
max pritikinWorking Group Participant Abstain Sat Nov 08 14:07:11 2008
Shah, HimanshuWorking Group Participant Approve Sun Nov 09 09:21:42 2008
Bob FrazierTask Force Participant Approve Mon Nov 10 05:49:00 2008
Brandner, Rudolf (NSN - DE/Munich)Working Group Participant Disapprove Mon Nov 10 08:53:23 2008
Pat ThalerWorking Group Participant Approve Fri Nov 14 14:34:37 2008
Osama Aboul-MagdClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Jan BialkowskiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Paul BottorffClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Frank ChaoClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Rao CherukuriClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Taesik CheungClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Alex ContaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Donald FedykClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Felix, FengClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Norman FinnClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Robert FrazierClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Franz GoetzClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Karanvir GrewalClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Brian HausauerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Anthony JeffreeClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Philippe KleinClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John MessengerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Dinesh MohanClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ken PattonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Hayim PoratClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ananda RajagopalClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Robert RodenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Guenter RoeckClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Moran RothClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ali SajassiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John SauerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ravi ShenoyClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Robert SultanClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
George SwallowClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Michael TeenerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John TerryClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Oliver ThorpClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Fred TuckClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
, WeisClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Bert WijnenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Michael, WrightClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A