IEEE 802.1 Web Tally
Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1Q-Rev/D1.2
Tallied VotesOther Information
Approve [*]17 (%74)Pass / Fail [**]Fail
Disapprove6 (%26)Last Updated2017-03-27
Abstain [*]17 (%43)Non-Voting Comments [*]0
Total40ParticipationClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List 40 / 96  Task Force 29
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve"
   Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain"
   Non-Voting Comments are just "Comments"
** To "Pass": Approval Percent >= 75% and Work Group Parcipation >= 50%

Ballot Votes
Participant Vote Date
Martin, DavidWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Wed Sep 01 16:12:48 2010
Geoffrey M. GarnerWorking Group Participant Comments (With Abstain) Wed Sep 01 16:50:29 2010
Muneyoshi SuzukiWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 06 20:41:57 2010
Yong KimWorking Group Participant Approve Tue Sep 07 03:48:11 2010
Derek RohdeWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 07 20:15:20 2010
SETO, KoichiroWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Sep 09 13:35:04 2010
John Nels FullerWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Sep 09 19:28:14 2010
Ben Mack-CraneWorking Group Participant Disapprove Fri Sep 10 11:23:07 2010
Olsen, DaveWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Sep 10 16:01:26 2010
Stanton, Kevin BWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Sep 10 16:57:52 2010
Glenn ParsonsWorking Group Participant Disapprove Fri Sep 10 17:00:50 2010
Joe Pelissier (jopeliss)Working Group Participant Approve Fri Sep 10 17:27:46 2010
Henry (Chien-Hsien) WuWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Sep 10 19:59:40 2010
Bob SultanTask Force Participant Disapprove Sun Sep 12 16:51:59 2010
Craig W. CarlsonWorking Group Participant Abstain Sun Sep 12 23:02:25 2010
Bruce KwanWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 13 03:11:05 2010
Claudio DeSantiWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 13 04:18:15 2010
Fedyk, Donald (Don)Working Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 13 04:51:21 2010
Bert Wijnen (802.1)Working Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 13 05:15:42 2010
Zhemin DINGWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 13 05:37:22 2010
Goetz, Franz-JosefWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 14 08:48:26 2010
Asif Q HazarikaWorking Group Participant Approve Tue Sep 14 10:25:39 2010
Diego CrupnicoffWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Jul 31 09:07:10 2013
Kiessling, MarcelTask Force Participant Comments (With Abstain) Thu Aug 08 10:45:43 2013
Jessy V RouyerWorking Group Participant Approve Tue Aug 13 23:52:15 2013
Philippe KleinWorking Group Participant Approve Wed Aug 14 04:43:24 2013
Tony JeffreeTask Force Participant Approve Wed Aug 14 13:16:34 2013
Wilfried SteinerTask Force Participant Approve Tue Aug 20 08:00:31 2013
Romascanu, Dan (Dan)Working Group Participant Approve Wed Aug 21 12:35:01 2013
Xiao MinTask Force Participant Approve Wed Aug 21 22:30:17 2013
Rakesh SharmaTask Force Participant Approve Thu Aug 22 15:46:17 2013
Mick SeamanWorking Group Participant Disapprove Fri Aug 23 02:17:33 2013
Hitoshi HayakawaTask Force Participant Abstain Fri Aug 23 08:07:25 2013
Karen RandallWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Aug 23 10:25:20 2013
Markus JochimTask Force Participant Abstain Fri Aug 23 11:10:56 2013
Norman Finn (nfinn)Working Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Fri Aug 23 16:01:20 2013
Hal KeenWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Aug 23 17:19:23 2013
Gunther, CraigWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Fri Aug 23 18:01:26 2013
Irene AoTask Force Participant Approve Fri Aug 23 22:27:23 2013
ben mackcraneWorking Group Participant Disapprove Sat Aug 24 20:07:31 2013
Daniel SextonTask Force Participant Approve Sun Aug 25 15:01:24 2013
Panagiotis SaltsidisWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Sun Aug 25 17:51:39 2013
Cheng, WeiyingWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Aug 26 04:06:13 2013
János FarkasTask Force Participant Approve Mon Aug 26 04:17:00 2013
Touve, Jeremy (Jeremy)Task Force Participant Approve Mon Aug 26 15:22:19 2013
Pat ThalerWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Tue Aug 27 00:57:36 2013
Multanen, Eric WWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Aug 27 01:24:09 2013
Don PannellTask Force Participant Abstain Tue Aug 27 05:21:38 2013
Jeffrey LynchTask Force Participant Approve Tue Sep 03 16:57:52 2013
Marina Gutierrez LopezTask Force Participant Abstain Thu Mar 02 10:59:05 2017
Stephan KehrerTask Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 06 11:16:33 2017
Geoffrey GarnerWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Mar 10 09:28:37 2017
Mark R. HantelTask Force Participant Approve Fri Mar 10 16:14:33 2017
Chen, David 1. (Nokia - US/Arlington Heights)Task Force Participant Approve Fri Mar 10 18:00:24 2017
Rodney CummingsTask Force Participant Approve Fri Mar 10 21:06:32 2017
Wang, HaoTask Force Participant Approve Sat Mar 11 06:08:53 2017
Riegel, Maximilian (Nokia - DE/Munich)Task Force Participant Approve Sat Mar 11 15:58:22 2017
Frank ScheweTask Force Participant Approve Sat Mar 11 19:27:35 2017
LiyizhouTask Force Participant Approve Sun Mar 12 20:44:43 2017
Christophe ManginTask Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 13 07:37:11 2017
Christian BoigerTask Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 13 11:08:52 2017
Nader ZeinTask Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 13 13:01:23 2017
Stephen HaddockWorking Group Participant Disapprove Mon Mar 13 14:12:29 2017
Patrick HeffernanTask Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 13 18:28:02 2017
Johannes SpechtTask Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 13 18:55:11 2017
Rouyer, Jessy (Nokia - US)Working Group Participant Approve Mon Mar 13 22:20:11 2017
John MessengerWorking Group Participant Disapprove Tue Mar 14 10:41:50 2017
Eric GrayWorking Group Participant Approve Thu Mar 16 11:12:29 2017
Bierschenk Jens (AE-BE/EKE1)Task Force Participant Approve Mon Mar 27 04:28:54 2017
Zehavit AlonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Siamack AyandehClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Jan BialkowskiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Jean-Michel BonnamyClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Paul BottorffClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Rudolf BrandnerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Rao CherukuriClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Jin-Seek ChoiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Paul CongdonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Don ConnorClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Linda DunbarClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
David Elie-Dit-CosaqueClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Janos FarkasClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Robert FrazierClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Anoop GhanwaniClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Karanvir GrewalClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Mitch GusatClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Charles HudsonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Romain InslerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Anthony JeffreeClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Pankaj JhaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Abhay KarandikarClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Prakash KashyapClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Keti KilcreaseClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Mike KoClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Vinod KumarClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Kari LaihonenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ashvin LakshmikanthaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John LemonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Marina LipshteynClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Gael MaceClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Alan McguireClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
James McintoshClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Menucher MenucheryClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Gabriel MontenegroClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Matthew MoraClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John MorrisClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Paul NikolichClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Kevin NolishClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Donald PannellClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
David PetersonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Hayim PoratClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Max PritikinClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Josef RoeseClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Jonathan SadlerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ali SajassiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Joseph SaloweyClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Satish SatheClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John SauerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Nurit SprecherClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Robert SultanClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Michael TeenerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ao TingClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Manoj WadekarClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Yuehua WeiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Weis BrianClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Martin WhiteClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ken YoungClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Glen ZornClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A