IEEE 802.1 Web Tally
Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1Qaw/D3.1
Tallied VotesOther Information
Approve [*]9 (%75)Pass / Fail [**]Fail
Disapprove3 (%25)Last Updated2008-09-17
Abstain [*]37 (%76)Non-Voting Comments [*]0
Total49ParticipationClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List 49 / 106  Task Force 4
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve"
   Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain"
   Non-Voting Comments are just "Comments"
** To "Pass": Approval Percent >= 75% and Work Group Parcipation >= 50%

Ballot Votes
Participant Vote Date
Mace GaelWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Aug 18 06:25:14 2008
Boatright, RobertWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Aug 18 10:44:46 2008
Geoffrey M. GarnerWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Aug 18 12:06:21 2008
Keti Kilcrease (kilcreas)Working Group Participant Abstain Tue Aug 19 12:36:13 2008
John Nels FullerWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Aug 21 00:43:03 2008
Guenter RoeckWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Aug 26 16:20:07 2008
Francois Tallet (ftallet)Working Group Participant Abstain Thu Aug 28 14:27:53 2008
David MartinWorking Group Participant Comments (With Approve) Fri Aug 29 13:41:09 2008
Menu MenuchehryWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Aug 29 18:33:40 2008
Stanton, Kevin BWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 02 17:35:03 2008
Satish SatheWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 02 20:55:00 2008
Ken YoungWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 03 00:24:11 2008
Grewal, KenWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 03 12:50:14 2008
Philippe KleinWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 03 13:44:54 2008
Michael WrightWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 03 18:44:18 2008
Winkel, LudwigWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Sep 04 03:38:35 2008
Joseph Salowey (jsalowey)Working Group Participant Abstain Thu Sep 04 18:02:34 2008
Mick SeamanTask Force Participant Disapprove Thu Sep 04 19:18:03 2008
Brian WeisWorking Group Participant Abstain Thu Sep 04 20:49:09 2008
Hal KeenWorking Group Participant Abstain Sat Sep 06 12:23:25 2008
Hesham ElbakouryWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 08 02:46:07 2008
yannick1 . legoffWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 08 05:30:59 2008
Romascanu, Dan (Dan)Working Group Participant Comments (With Abstain) Mon Sep 08 06:43:00 2008
Sauer, John M.Working Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 15:27:21 2008
Janos FarkasWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 15:49:46 2008
Don PannellWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 17:25:16 2008
Manoj WadekarWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 18:14:07 2008
Ben Mack-CraneWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 08 19:00:19 2008
Congdon, Paul T (ProCurve)Working Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 19:26:57 2008
Joe Pelissier (jopeliss)Task Force Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 19:28:30 2008
Henry (Chien-Hsien) WuWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 19:47:25 2008
Craig W. CarlsonWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 20:51:25 2008
Osama Aboul-MagdWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 08 21:05:23 2008
Prakash KashyapWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 08 21:40:11 2008
Jessy V RouyerWorking Group Participant Disapprove Mon Sep 08 22:02:54 2008
Kevin NolishWorking Group Participant Comments (With Abstain) Mon Sep 08 22:30:38 2008
Bob SultanWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 08 22:56:48 2008
David Elie-Dit-CosaqueWorking Group Participant Disapprove Mon Sep 08 23:22:50 2008
Bruce KwanWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 09 02:09:04 2008
Stephen HaddockTask Force Participant Disapprove Tue Sep 09 02:39:45 2008
Claudio DeSantiWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 09 03:33:11 2008
Oliver ThorpWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 09 06:36:31 2008
Goetz, Franz-JosefWorking Group Participant Abstain Tue Sep 09 13:14:46 2008
Glenn ParsonsWorking Group Participant Disapprove Tue Sep 09 13:33:39 2008
Hayim PoratWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 10 06:25:27 2008
Eric GrayWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 10 11:38:16 2008
Jan BialkowskiWorking Group Participant Approve Wed Sep 10 16:07:54 2008
Linda DunbarWorking Group Participant Approve Wed Sep 10 16:12:33 2008
Abhay KarandikarTask Force Participant Abstain Thu Sep 11 11:17:41 2008
Alan McGuireWorking Group Participant Abstain Fri Sep 12 13:32:31 2008
Bob FrazierWorking Group Participant Approve Mon Sep 15 04:13:28 2008
Panagiotis SaltsidisWorking Group Participant Abstain Mon Sep 15 09:35:11 2008
Riccardo MartinottiWorking Group Participant Abstain Wed Sep 17 12:39:56 2008
Zehavit AlonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Caitlin BestlerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Jean-Michel BonnamyClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Paul BottorffClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Rudolf BrandnerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Frank ChaoClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Rao CherukuriClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Taesik CheungClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Alex ContaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Diego CrupnicoffClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Don FedykClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Felix FengClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Norm FinnClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Anoop GhanwaniClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Craig GuntherClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Mitch GusatClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Steve HaddockClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Brian HassinkClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Brian HausauerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Asif HazarikaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Romain InslerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Tony JeffreeClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Paul JeongClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Michael TeenerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Yongbum KimClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Mike KoClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Raghu KondapalliClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Kari LaihonenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Marco MascittoClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John MessengerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Dinesh MohanClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Hiroshi OhtaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
David OlsenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Shlomo OvadiaClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ken PattonClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Joe PelissierClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Max PritikinClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ananda RajagopalClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Karen RandallClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Robert RodenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Josef RoeseClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Moran RothClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ali SajassiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Mick SeamanClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Koichiro SetoClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Himanshu ShahClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Ravi ShenoyClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Nurit SprecherClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Muneyoshi SuzukiClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
George SwallowClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Attila TakacsClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
John TerryClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Pat ThalerClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Fred TuckClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Maarten VissersClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Yan WangClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A
Bert WijnenClick to see a Hard Copy of the Voters List No Vote N/A